Saturday, January 9, 2010

Every Little Thing is Going to be Alright. Or All Right?

Did you know that there is a debate going on whether or not "alright" is a word. Grammarians argue that it is not--that it should always be "all right." But *I* have to argue with that. To me, "all right" means one thing, while "alright" means something different.
The distinction, in my mind, is slight, but there. I don't think I would say, "All right, let's get moving." But to me, "Alright, let's get moving!" is acceptable.

Merriam-Webster says that "all right" means:
all right
adjective
1. satisfactory, agreeable <Whatever you decide is all right with me.>
2. safe, well <He was sick, but he is all right now.>
3. good, pleasing --often used as a generalized term of approval. <He was an all right guy.>

So which definition would fit in the previous sentence? None of them, really. Unless you mean it is agreeable to get moving, but that just isn't what it means to me in that context. So then the next question is, what *does* it mean to me in that context? And my answer: I don't really know. Scary, huh? I've been using a word, that is not *really* a word and I don't really know how to define it either.

Upon further research, I found this at "The Free Dictionary."

all right

adj.
1.
a. In proper or satisfactory operational or working order: checked to see if the tires were all right.
b. Acceptable; agreeable: Delaying the repair is all right by me.
c. all-right (ôlrt) Informal Satisfactory; good: an all-right fellow; an all-right movie.
2. Correct: Your answers are all right.
3. Average; mediocre: The performance was just all right, not remarkable.
4. Uninjured; safe: The passengers were shaken up but are all right.
5. Fairly healthy; well: I am feeling all right again.
adv.
1. In a satisfactory way; adequately: I held up all right under pressure.
2. Very well; yes. Used as a reply to a question or to introduce a declaration: All right, I'll go.
3. Without a doubt: It's cold, all right.
Usage Note: Despite the appearance of the form alright in works of such well-known writers as Langston Hughes and James Joyce, the single word spelling has never been accepted as standard. This is peculiar, since similar fusions such as already and altogether have never raised any objections. The difference may lie in the fact that already and altogether became single words back in the Middle Ages, whereas alright has only been around for a little more than a century and was called out by language critics as a misspelling. Consequently, one who uses alright, especially in formal writing, runs the risk that readers may view it as an error or as the willful breaking of convention.

But M-W says that "alright" is gaining some acceptance. As does Mignon. But they also claim that it is not accepted yet.

Moral of the story? I guess it would be don't use "alright" because it isn't a word.
That makes me sad, somehow.



3 comments:

  1. The OED is the dictionary of record for English professionals. The Oxford English Dictionary lists "alright" as both an alternative to "all right" and as an obscure adverb, with quotations dating to the 1100s. As a rhetorician, I was always taught that language adjusts to the needs of the people rather than the other way around. So use alright with impunity. Your English professor will never argue with the OED.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Aw, man! I feel like I did when they declared that Pluto was no longer a planet. Neither is alright (or all right) with me! Oh well, no one asked.

    I was just talking with Brian tonight about how I think "funner" should be a word because it sounds exactly like what it describes. Avery used it accidentally and I just think it sounds more fun than "more fun". Oh well, again, no one asked. :D

    ReplyDelete
  3. I guess in "formal" writing it is looked down upon, but in is okay in informal.
    And I am all about the flexibility of the English language. I didn't know you were a rhetorician, Xan. My favorite class was the rhetoric of language and I still have the text!
    I think I need to get an OED. Obviously the internet isn't cutting it in that regard!
    And maybe if we keep using alright, it will get its own definition. I am afraid that we cannot say the same about Pluto. :(

    ReplyDelete